| Overall: 28-9 (.756) |
| 1992 | Alter at Trotwood Madison | 38 - 28 | W |
| 1992 | Little Miami at Welcome Stadium | 28 - 21 | W |
| 1992 | Ironton at Dublin | 0 - 23 | L |
| 1993 | London at Welcome Stadium | 24 - 13 | W |
| 1993 | Hamilton Badin at Barnitz Stadium | 20 - 14 | W |
| 1993 | Ironton at Welcome Stadium | 9 - 23 | L |
| 1994 | Columbus Bishop Ready at Stebbins | 32 - 21 | W |
| 1994 | Cincinnati Wyoming at Fairfield | 49 - 33 | W |
| 1994 | Wheelersburg at Col. Groveport | 24 - 7 | W |
| 1994 | Orrville at Massillon Stadium | 34 - 24 | W |
| 1995 | Col. Bishop Ready at Spring. South | 22 - 6 | W |
| 1995 | Versailles at Welcome Stadium | 8 - 35 | L |
| 1996 | Indian Hill at Hamilton | 41 - 14 | W |
| 1996 | Wyoming at Fairfield | 34 - 14 | W |
| 1996 | Margaretta at Lima | 28 - 13 | W |
| 1996 | Bellaire at Massillon Stadium | 37 - 12 | W |
| 1997 | Jonathon Alder at Xenia | 40 - 7 | W |
| 1997 | Ottawa Glandorf at Troy | 36 - 22 | W |
| 1997 | Bellaire at Lancaster | 27 - 19 | W |
| 1997 | Manchester at Massillon | 31 - 24 | W 5 OTs |
| 1998 | Ironton at Washington C.H. | 50 - 20 | W |
| 1998 | Wyoming at Hamilton | 18 - 28 | L |
| 1999 | Porstmouth at Porstmouth Spartan Stadium | 37 - 16 | W |
| 1999 | Wheelersburg at Princeton | | W |
| 1999 | Ironton at Princeton | 29 - 37 | L |
| 2000 | Madeira at Barker Field | 53 - 7 | W |
| 2000 | Minford at Hilliard | 55 - 13 | W |
| 2000 | Wyoming at Fairfield | 41 - 23 | W |
| 2000 | Coldwater at Troy | 15 - 41 | L |
| 2001 | Hamilton Badin at Barker Field | 23 - 16 | L |
| 2002 | Wyoming at Barker Field | 31 - 21 | W |
| 2002 | Tipp City at Northmont | 24 - 10 | W |
| 2002 | Urbana at Welcome Stadium | 55 - 20 | W |
| 2002 | Watterson at Welcome Stadium | 14 - 40 | L |
| 2003 | Bellbrook at Bellbrook | 35 - 21 | W |
| 2003 | Wyoming at Mason Dwire Stadium | 34 - 26 | W |
| 2003 | Licking Valley at Grove City | 60-63 | L 4OTs |
